A Zillow estimate or county tax value can help you gather information, but neither automatically establishes your tax basis in an inherited house. You need a value for the right date, with records that support it.
That gets confusing when the tax notice says one thing, Zillow says another, and your accountant asks what the house was worth when its owner died. Before choosing a number, check what each one actually measures.
Which value do you need for an inherited house?
The IRS says inherited property’s basis generally starts with its fair market value on the owner’s date of death. Basis is the amount used to help calculate a gain or loss when you sell. An alternate valuation date can apply to certain estates that make the election on a federal estate tax return.
Ask the executor whether the estate already has an appraisal or reported value. If you received Schedule A to Form 8971, give it to your accountant. Certain inherited property must use a basis consistent with the value finally determined for federal estate tax purposes.
Don’t assume a new estimate replaces an existing estate value. Your accountant should confirm the applicable rules before you order more work.
Can you use a Zillow estimate?
Zillow says a Zestimate is not an appraisal and cannot replace one. Its model uses public records, listing data, and home details. Missing or incorrect information can affect the estimate.
There is also a timing problem. Today’s estimate answers a different question from what the home was worth two years ago. Even a historical estimate doesn’t, by itself, explain the house’s condition on the date you need.
Suppose the family replaced a leaking roof and remodeled the kitchen after inheriting the house. Save photos and receipts showing when that work happened. A current listing may show a home that looks quite different from the one the owner left.
Keep useful listing records, but ask your accountant what evidence the tax file needs before relying on an online number.
Can you use the county tax assessment?
Check the label and valuation date first. A property’s market value, appraised value, and taxable value can differ. The number used to calculate a property tax bill may reflect exemptions or appraisal limits.
In Texas, appraisal districts generally value property as of January 1. The Texas Comptroller explains the valuation process and homestead appraisal limits. If the owner died in September, a January value doesn’t automatically answer the September question.
The county record is still worth saving. It can help identify the parcel, building details, and valuation history. Give your accountant the full record, including its date and any exemptions, rather than a single dollar amount copied from the bill. Outside Texas, check the local assessor’s definitions and valuation date.
What does a date-of-death appraisal add?
A date-of-death appraisal addresses a specific past date. The appraiser researches the property and relevant market evidence, then explains the value conclusion in a written report.
Historical condition matters. The Appraisal Institute’s guidance on retrospective valuations discusses using the best available information about a property as it existed on the valuation date. Tell the appraiser about changes since the death and flag details you cannot verify.
If an appraisal differs from Zillow or the tax record, ask about the reason. Compare the dates, property details, and condition before treating the difference as an error. Ask which sales support the conclusion and how the report accounts for differences between those homes and yours.
What to gather before paying for another report
You don’t need a perfect file to make the first call. Gather what you have:
- The property address, parcel number, and date of death.
- Any appraisal or valuation already obtained by the estate.
- The full county property record for the relevant year.
- Dated photos, old listings, and inspection reports.
- A short timeline of repairs or renovations after the death.
- Sale and closing records if the house has already sold.
Then ask your accountant: “Do we already have enough support for the basis, or do you need a retrospective appraisal?” If a report is needed, confirm the valuation date and intended use with the appraiser. Share any filing deadline before agreeing to the work.
If nobody arranged an appraisal at the time, it may still be possible to get a date-of-death appraisal years later. If the property has sold, see our guide to getting an appraisal after an inherited-house sale.
Contact Retroactive Appraisal Group with the address, date of death, and records you have. Tell us whether your accountant or attorney has requested a particular type of report so we can review the request.
See also: why today’s market value isn’t the date-of-death value · date of death appraisal for estate tax





